Food Authenticity: Who Owns the Word “Authentic”? Our Students Ask Three Experts

“Authentic.” “Local.” “Traditional.” Three words that sell dishes on menus, labels and tourist brochures, and that no law defines. Who gets to decide what they mean? And what does it cost when the decision is left to the market?

On Wednesday 11 November, students of our Master in Gastronomic Journalism and Communication and our Dual Master in Travel and Gastronomic Journalism put the question of food authenticity to three experts in a live debate, with around 40 people in the room. Here are the five ideas about food authenticity that stayed with us.

Food authenticity: who owns the word authentic? Live student debate at the School of Travel Journalism

1. “Authentic” on a menu may be a warning sign

The panel opened with a quick round on what the word promises when we talk about food authenticity. The British food writer Carolyn Boyd, author of Amuse-Bouche: How to Eat Your Way Around France, said that a place that announces it is authentic is often less so. Truly local products rarely need to say it. Food historian Peter Gilchrist agreed and asked for something simpler: ingredients that local people would recognise, grown by local producers.

2. A name can be taken away from the people who made it

The co-moderator told the story of wild rice and the Ojibwe people of Minnesota: when farmers began growing the same plant in flooded paddies and selling it under the same name, shoppers could not tell the difference, prices fell and a community lost its income. Roman Zastserinski, the Estonian chef behind the restaurants Moon and Kolm Sibulat in Tallinn, took a relaxed view. If someone profits from a family recipe, he said, they are still promoting the cuisine. Not everyone at the table agreed, and that was the point.

3. Protection works, until it grows too big

Boyd explained how European designations such as AOC/AOP and IGP give communities a sense of ownership of their products, a legal answer to the food authenticity question. She also described a cooperative that grew so large that independent artisans could no longer afford to produce outside it. Gilchrist, who is campaigning for the Scottish morning roll to be recognised by UNESCO, warned that a designation can flatten a whole food culture into one product and erase its regional varieties.

4. Tradition is whatever people still cook and love

Is injera still injera if it is made with rice or wheat flour because teff exports were banned? Is a Scottish lasagne authentic? Gilchrist argued that food authenticity belongs to the people who eat the dish: if it tastes like the one their grandmother made, it counts. Zastserinski added that the “original” Slavic cuisine of 150 years ago would find few diners today.

5. The internet now decides what is authentic

On food authenticity, search engines and AI keep repeating the same quirky clichés (haggis and whisky for Scotland, for example). Boyd described tracing a dandelion jam that a dozen websites called a local speciality. In the mountains where it was supposedly beloved, nobody had heard of it, and she eventually found a single jar. Her lesson for journalists: ask why, why, why, and go and check.

Three words, three definitions of food authenticity

At the start, each panellist wrote three words defining “authentic”. At the end they revealed them:

  • Boyd: terroir, local, belonging
  • Gilchrist: history, egalitarian, discipline
  • Zastserinski: sauerkraut (a dish shared across four cultures in his country), generations, simple, working-class

The audience also gave their own answer to a question from the moderators: how many miles is “local”? Replies ranged from 10 miles to 100 km, with one reader saying there is no limit at all.

A team of students behind the screen

Behind the camera were around twenty students working in moderation, production, research, booking, technical support, reporting and communications. They spent three weeks preparing the questions, the script and the guests for this debate on food authenticity.

Shivani Rane moderated, with Daniel Llewelyn-Williams as co-moderator, and the two handed the conversation back and forth so naturally that it felt like a talk between friends. Adina Dumitrescu and Michaela Smolová ran production and kept the time without cutting anyone off. Letícia Bento and Isabella Straus looked after the technical side. Ramona Smith and Lucy Bryson led the research, Victor Santos, Marina Zastrogina and Molly O’Kane booked the guests, María Díaz and Elli Geniatakis worked as rapporteurs, and Louise Davies led communications. The audience grew from 36 to 40 people during the session.

Congratulations to everyone involved, and our thanks to our three guests.

Why food authenticity matters for food journalists

Anyone writing about food, restaurants or destinations uses these words every day. Learning to question them, to check a claim before repeating it, and to ask who benefits from a label is part of the job. That is exactly what our students practised when they debated food authenticity in public.

Learn gastronomic journalism and food authenticity by doing it

The Master in Gastronomic Journalism and Communication combines live projects like this one with masterclasses and published work. A second debate follows in January. If you are a producer, restaurant, destination or media outlet and would like to work with our students, talk to our content agency team.

Enjoying what you read?

Get the new articles from the School of Travel Journalism blog in your inbox every two weeks. No spam; unsubscribe anytime.

Leave a Comment

Contact

School of Travel Journalism S.L.

CIF: B44734986

BARCELONA, SPAIN

+44 7361587597

hola@schooloftraveljournalism.com

In partnership with